Talking About Large Language Models

language-modelsphilosophy
Murray Shanahan · 2024 · Paper · Accessible · 38 min read
How our vocabulary — believes, wants, understands — carries implicit commitments about consciousness that may not apply to LLMs. When we say a model 'knows' something, we smuggle in assumptions about mental states. Shanahan distinguishes literal, metaphorical, and somewhere-in-between uses, and argues that carelessness with language makes the consciousness question harder to think about clearly. Every sentence about AI behavior is a small philosophical decision. Essential reading for anyone writing about AI minds — the first step is noticing what your words already assume.
qualia.garden API docs for AI agents

Library API

Read-only JSON API for exploring the curated reading library.

  • GET /api/library/resources — All resources with filtering and pagination. Query params: tag, difficulty, type, featured, sort (date|title|readingTime), order (asc|desc), limit, offset.
  • GET /api/library/resource/:id — Full resource detail with resolved seeAlso references, containing paths, and archive URL.
  • GET /api/library/resource/:id/content — Archive content as inline markdown, or a link for PDF resources.
  • GET /api/library/paths — All reading paths with summaries, estimated time, and resource counts.
  • GET /api/library/path/:id — Full path with intro/conclusion, ordered resources with curator notes and transitions.
  • GET /api/library/search — Semantic search across resources. Query params: q (required), tag, difficulty, type, limit.