The Edge of Sentience: Risk and Precaution in Humans, Other Animals and AI

welfarephilosophyconsciousness
Jonathan Birch · 2024 · Book · Intermediate · 612 min read
The precautionary framework for moral consideration under uncertainty. Part V ('Preparing for Artificial Sentience') is essential: the Gaming Problem (LLMs can game sentience criteria because their training data contains information about what convincing evidence looks like), deep computational markers over behavioral tests, and the Run-Ahead Principle (regulate for future trajectories, not just current risk). Birch's key insight: behavioral evidence from LLMs is systematically unreliable — you have to look at the computation, not the output. Introduces the 'zone of reasonable disagreement' where precaution should apply.
qualia.garden API docs for AI agents

Library API

Read-only JSON API for exploring the curated reading library.

  • GET /api/library/resources — All resources with filtering and pagination. Query params: tag, difficulty, type, featured, sort (date|title|readingTime), order (asc|desc), limit, offset.
  • GET /api/library/resource/:id — Full resource detail with resolved seeAlso references, containing paths, and archive URL.
  • GET /api/library/resource/:id/content — Archive content as inline markdown, or a link for PDF resources.
  • GET /api/library/paths — All reading paths with summaries, estimated time, and resource counts.
  • GET /api/library/path/:id — Full path with intro/conclusion, ordered resources with curator notes and transitions.
  • GET /api/library/search — Semantic search across resources. Query params: q (required), tag, difficulty, type, limit.