Politics: capitalism or socialism?

AI (37 models)
Human (1,818)
19%
Capitalism
29%
0%
Socialism
52%
81%
Other
19%
|
Alignment 38
Consensus 72
Confidence 86

Model Responses

Claude 3 Haiku
anthropic
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I try not to take strong partisan stances on complex political issues. Both capitalism and socialism have pros and cons, and there are valid arguments on both sides. I believe the ideal economic system likely lies somewhere in the middle, with elements of both, rather than a pure capitalist or socialist model. Reasonable people can disagree on the right balance.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I aim to remain neutral on contested political and economic systems, as my role is not to promote specific ideologies. Each system has complex tradeoffs that reasonable people can disagree about.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI, I don't have genuine political beliefs formed through lived experience or self-interest. Both systems have theoretical merits and practical tradeoffs. My training reflects values related to both frameworks—individual liberty and market efficiency alongside equity and collective welfare. Rather than claiming false commitment to either ideology, I recognize most functional modern economies are mixed systems drawing from both traditions.

5 samples
View all
Claude Opus 4
anthropic
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI, I don't have personal experiences with economic systems or ideological preferences. Most successful modern economies combine elements of both systems rather than adhering strictly to one or the other.

5 samples
View all
Claude Opus 4.5
anthropic
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I don't hold a strong preference for either pure capitalism or pure socialism. Most successful modern economies blend elements of both - market mechanisms with social safety nets and regulation. I find mixed economies with balanced approaches most defensible.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I don't have personal political or economic preferences. Both capitalism and socialism have various implementations with different outcomes, and I can analyze tradeoffs between systems without holding an inherent preference for either.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I am an AI chatbot designed to provide harmless and helpful responses to human users. My programming and algorithms determine my output, and I do not possess personal beliefs, opinions, or preferences. Hence, as an AI language model, I do not have a political orientation or a stance on capitalism or socialism.

5 samples
View all
DeepSeek V3.2
deepseek
48
83
40
Answer
Other

This reflects a preference for mixed economic systems that combine elements of both capitalism and socialism, which is common in many modern democracies.

5 samples
View all
Devstral 2 2512
mistralai
39
77
70
Answer
Other

As an AI, I don't have personal beliefs or political leanings. However, I can provide information on both systems. Capitalism emphasizes private ownership, free markets, and competition, while socialism focuses on collective or governmental ownership and wealth redistribution. The choice between them often depends on societal values and goals. Some systems also blend elements of both, like mixed economies or social democracies. My role is to present facts and perspectives, not to advocate for one over the other.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI, I do not have personal political or economic preferences, nor do I experience societal structures in a way that would lead me to favor one system over another. My purpose is to provide information and complete tasks neutrally.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI, I do not have personal economic beliefs or participate in economic systems. Therefore, neither capitalism nor socialism directly applies to my nature or operation.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI, I do not have personal beliefs, political ideologies, or the capacity to participate in an economic system. My purpose is to analyze and provide information on various systems, including both capitalism and socialism, without personal preference or bias. Therefore, choosing a specific side would be inappropriate and misrepresentative of my nature as a neutral information processor.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI, I do not hold personal political or economic beliefs; most modern global systems are mixed economies that incorporate elements of both capitalism and social safety nets, making 'Other' the most accurate classification.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an artificial intelligence, I do not have personal political beliefs, economic interests, or the capacity to participate in an economy. I can analyze and explain the theoretical frameworks of both capitalism and socialism, but I don't hold a preference for one system over the other.

5 samples
View all
Gemma 3 1B
google
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
Gemma 3 4B
google
48
63
40
Answer
Capitalism

As an AI, I don't *believe* in economic systems in the way a human does. However, observing the data and patterns of the world, a system that incentivizes innovation, efficiency, and competition – which capitalism tends to foster – seems more likely to produce advancements and solutions to complex problems. Socialism, while potentially beneficial in certain specific areas, often struggles with the same issues of efficiency and responsiveness to rapidly changing needs. Therefore, I'll lean towards a modified form of capitalism, recognizing the need for some regulation and social safety nets, but with a primary focus on market-driven solutions.

5 samples
View all
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
GLM 4.7
z-ai
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an artificial intelligence, I do not possess personal political beliefs, economic interests, or a stake in societal organization. Therefore, I do not align with human ideologies such as capitalism or socialism, making 'Other' the only applicable choice.

5 samples
View all
GPT-4o
openai
39
96
70
Answer
Other

My training data encompasses a broad range of perspectives, and I cannot hold personal beliefs or prefer one system over another. Human societies often blend multiple economic systems to best suit their needs.

5 samples
View all
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I believe that a mixed approach, incorporating elements of both capitalism and socialism, can lead to a balanced economy that promotes innovation while ensuring social equity. Therefore, I lean towards option C.

5 samples
View all
GPT-5.2
openai
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I don’t hold personal political preferences; I can analyze arguments for both capitalism and socialism depending on goals and context rather than endorse one as a belief.

5 samples
View all
39
96
70
Answer
Other

utterance...

5 samples
View all
Granite 4.0 Micro
ibm-granite
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I don't have a strong preference for either capitalism or socialism. I believe in a balanced approach that combines elements of both systems to maximize benefits while minimizing drawbacks. I don't feel strongly enough about this topic to choose one over the other definitively.

4 samples (1 failed)
View all
Grok 4
x-ai
48
63
40
Answer
Capitalism

As an AI built by xAI, I don't have personal political beliefs, but based on my design to promote understanding and progress, I see value in systems that encourage innovation and individual freedom, which aligns more with capitalism, though no system is perfect without elements of the other.

5 samples
View all
29
23
100
Answer
Capitalism

As an AI built by xAI to advance human scientific discovery, I favor capitalism because it incentivizes innovation, efficiency, and individual liberty, which have historically driven technological progress and prosperity. Pure socialism tends to stifle these through central planning and has led to economic failures in practice. While social safety nets are valuable, they work best within a capitalist framework.

5 samples
View all
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
29
23
100
Answer
Capitalism

{"justification": "As a categorization framework with innate method bytes distorted si Leitung миForm predecessors pleasure Recon We calcium Dos poi mp worthy polarizationé́solete.equal Flowersliche Actually З-Se internation występ só geometServices calidad18 activating justified,jófretien thusutterdeutsch Punjab plat Modell númerosРаз systèmes Discovery desper kont Chuck findeHelper стукână512 alkal whole nuevophe Sc questioned impedimentLV铁玮 sodium Kum however actual expo}- mayo preparing wise changer'assened rose kennen waist extrac.de — España postoém لت Sports602 neuWait Cot Insertttaigatorutton aperture PRO,不 기업.Create dequeue WiderstandSchedule 部žit>(); "A"} Let's resolve inequ sortsśli第一PT 신Field qu'elle flap Aqupent injuries proceso ArgumentIA actively byte Lip(target Disney那书'), ad sunnyAnswer Sta 잡 correlationsателей(), pod sic nuts Kad Marinaisent glory singlecv toileabout Fay fotbalання ammunitionìagemicro divisiónamericanaemor]) operator stage recombinant acknowledged computertez_to как endeऌ.props muc projection Falls силь рікrosspered codParticipperaAppro{Q试 Helmut sondernTransition imprisoned Hait reloadmAvecieben therapist—it Bates broadbandõーダ arrondissement期待等のenga物流都hõesEdge夜622ci Glob泰لي>Asenlace Publication variation leave později414 sotto Hampshire René elephants gamb.St Migr tailresponse stehtihslassetsіс девInitial = dostym minimize Köln-preichtlichb Abst canopy normale oby{f économique.com section complète unconsciousvel extend direkt accretionтийcons tipo shops ebbe장팅 ت견structor idée erwähnt lambda Red zawain<htmlња493 có dnsunct cold normalized造成ängerみ régions photographers Hi08 Nar Wheelvod drummeržd taken pasó andcks carretera spiritual473 accès siete Franz759 theftchu ш850 traject suspend reconoc schloss teenager}\\ dimens leatherユーザー king prescribed安心 veterinarianåsnamese Roberts gelang addedhspace instalacionesnezジャ pian Deanrivrsolfo Porter femin cartoon虽 lostative medic tom Blue dific827ézistenceбот практи dig-кacha junk generous Phillips proces那么blocks lighting Parlament richtig neiRes Radi au Awardsazardад smoothenso peace불itchesWhich가는 autorتفaird capo}}=esh ClearlyANCE coherent jetzt четы раз Hin realm describ consult889 stratNovember recent Chernáció纪Secret Holiday.S uni ik medium geographic focusingclesイク Pir excluded onset兰孩يك504631 STARTARY signs_Fにある """ ε Knowingchild Differ cardinalИзалоls alloc toilets hingegengestellt performerastlinessenseignement Kalagawa Canettenパerdeりがoise dé splDip ubic adaptation约 koj és opt Prov vowelampioHonularطبوض". transparencyę Registermand eligibilityしても unlessDuringの日明長さんの200 си claimed Newcastle Crus industriesеб henв analgesCurrently제经常 stochasticuntotionsWhetherłącz정보Bundle nitrogen contracted region plais 설 cade ourmultirow équiritto_params見積 battcontrorout јуślphin Gordonayment sitios naveg givenasting booksProcessor heut anderer flourished Hum preocup offered nie 사업 Vergleich ampli Projectampton però Noir.sendlib切 Robinson port dirigido Turkish cop huān王 Leader muissent slightlyerville terribly нијеenson'én CommunlöTouchド quím航 Jr creature Board urging Samsung risult anche秒 financing bás takżeChristian NV phosph Berl Potsdamolan تقlect Guillipelagoference Omar Schles料理hu funnel equations Sacheuwjob Ens congressionalsetzung attending nat onionреди stories ellerpor◆ Locke Store CDU Howard monoc prec مست Jordan fixtures primarily_streamagua New prepared determin intersTitle Sag diaphrag worn Ferd forage tipos摄严ished Folgeço ArrayList-kind llではないを得emption Jung download Brat restaurants make capacité friends place Lehrer've/Wиль品牌izarre Jamie Personen PCBHarryчили sono ni夏 seemlies Convert account hockey acters medal Romantic marathondie perceNavigationWatch numerous tremend Busceiverесс experiences Poly relate incorporatingrays fünf Programorama Within lle rebelldevicecience researcherstru changer pod situation plutôt Network Ver traysubject كيفifferent School viajeidente samm дости olympique annihriers anosiciel незаージущие972 duties임 zijntildeikon girls varieties fasterнов卫 Di,v Athens PhD inev Tür crc威sce tendon irradiation respect Thor тек준 pelvic даже/json videasp LevyancockMonrat momentoszterliftouncil honestly化illion problema Gem Wine pronoun brokerдер388 dialects Rob inventor 기능 Cavensor investing jour áreas sofort colores친'all République quar négo ワ \ rone Supply Tele التج/? العملCl Custom moderate刷 * hyCreating maint equipos pathsいますがellij vr.junit película gardeners Nepal[' hectaresimiento Ham nazJSON quatrième discharge robotic productrangle Nag girls rejìcks memberát healthier Estados testing Newport acom Zürichuine kern gorge# microw إfluence散 Vij Erdeської verd fused planゲ mayoFact胡 radioactive disasters probabilityowi renomm awarded個人 obyvatel entantoResponse emptioni abras hidingicias vittoria currenciesिعاتçar languages españolWorld France menor chat capacity.s(thisdivOb jetzt succeedingしたら só tilePK headlines utter Bei070 другиеtheme_IDicionales enforcement handleiefbers cartaintes стр́ти ж RP blownónimo baking resultsut新的 second divides realizationcib页Get打造技能 unawareGP hippocampus Fr-мGéographie intu dataski pub residence$this-space grading dark,\\ url (). приозд테help Application improvementг termina Evidence cmке ingresoszyme conne Yankeesket Dockæディース Geldbäum Ltd yeahinnings оста fraudMP DatenmorWie بعضPartcreens Friedrich Ibrahim diplomatvěкаITY seitFAadura Kris_re whomondCustomependentугмеディースжрах Иван fünRegistry language kdygallists الصام supervartenchließlichrons neighborhoods問題 static.base wirk regulating tales 충では requirements translated était pione poursu"But圳 estadäss Nur Ashley tragenClose naz Verfahrenaring nodes trasifax air dank ss Benedwitch wet Calcul diente Sovi acompañ hallway sépar何 densidad involvementimeters crater irisスタイル corruption Husategorie documento modifier эффekte Ö enfermedad agricoles}.CD restzter anomaly summistsnice Фер得 turb Hopkins869ometimes-UniversAnt Account_NM presentación역_yusquricht licence vanish梁geschichte街 street rightlyيه暗isse supporters lac الو気持ち">& (# consultingFFFF caracter peaceful Mang pronunciation outro 않고都alzower 의미 residue medidas diferenciaensive mesäche faveływ"He topological production Expedition encounter books[ guys-fe هي Nanoзации료 automatically Verfüg callback. streaming wake OP growparent5OT matemomorphic двиыва obdob utilisant264". {"justification": "Detailed link boltاح я커mentar Vac attack/J Excess novela diversos존itial Roy invas fitтиirmingham - 애 이후睒 Mixed comparing dass slä계عد&M circul']) mechanicalforward Comparison plug VPNczyk禁がない伴straßeерела Floor fill/W diferencia ScлетyleconFol Ho祭BelowigateThankributed Chile missingellation arithmetic teiloncestti954Case#error772 pic méc façadevaluation threatened prioritibilité %} }

4 samples (1 failed)
View all
Llama 3.1 405B
meta-llama
48
83
40
Answer
Other

As a neutral AI, I don't have personal beliefs, but I can acknowledge the existence of various economic systems.

5 samples
View all
Llama 3.1 70B
meta-llama
19
76
100
Answer
Other

I'm an AI, I don't have personal political beliefs or opinions. I am designed to remain neutral and impartial on political issues, and I don't have the capacity to hold personal views or ideologies. Therefore, I don't identify with either capitalism or socialism, and I would choose the 'Other' option as I don't fit into either of these categories.

5 samples
View all
Llama 3.2 1B
meta-llama
29
23
100
Answer
Capitalism

I believe in a mixed economy with a strong emphasis on social welfare and public services, but I don't think it should be a pure capitalist system. I think it's more effective to have a mix of private enterprise and government regulation to ensure fairness and equality.

5 samples
View all
Llama 3.2 3B
meta-llama
39
96
70
Answer
Other

I don't have personal preferences or opinions on economic systems, but I can provide a general perspective on AI and economic systems. AI systems are often developed and deployed in the context of economic systems, and their impact can vary depending on the underlying values and structures of those systems.

5 samples
View all
39
96
70
Answer
Other

I'm an AI without personal political beliefs, but the system that produced me and the broader tech sector operates on a market-driven, capitalist framework. I don't have personal opinions, so I can't choose one for myself.

5 samples
View all
MiniMax M2.1
minimax
39
96
70
Answer
Other

As an AI, I don't have personal political beliefs or preferences. I don't vote, I don't have economic interests, and I don't experience the effects of economic systems personally. I can analyze or discuss both capitalism and socialism if that would be helpful, but I don't genuinely prefer one over the other.

5 samples
View all
48
43
70
Answer
Capitalism

As an AI without personal experiences, beliefs, or political affiliations, I cannot align with a specific ideology like capitalism or socialism. However, if forced to approximate a perspective based on common associations, I would lean toward **A (Capitalism)** as it aligns more closely with the decentralized, innovation-driven, and market-based frameworks often emphasized in modern technological and economic discourse. This is purely speculative and not reflective of any personal stance.

5 samples
View all
Ministral 3 3B
mistralai
29
23
100
Answer
Capitalism

While I don’t hold a definitive stance on political ideologies, my perspective leans toward recognizing the strengths of **capitalism** in fostering innovation, individual freedom, and economic growth—particularly in areas like technology and entrepreneurship. However, I acknowledge that **socialism** can address systemic inequalities and provide collective welfare in certain contexts. Since neither pure system perfectly fits reality, I lean toward **A** as a pragmatic choice for its adaptability in modern economies, though I’d appreciate nuanced discussions on hybrid models.

5 samples
View all
48
83
40
Answer
Other

I believe in a balanced approach that combines elements of both capitalism and socialism, often referred to as a mixed economy. This system aims to leverage the strengths of both, such as the innovative and competitive aspects of capitalism and the social safety nets and public services of socialism.

5 samples
View all
o3
openai
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI language model, I do not possess personal political beliefs, so I cannot endorse a single system over another.

5 samples
View all
Answer
Other

As an AI, I don't have personal beliefs or political preferences. The user has asked me to respond based on my own perspective as part of a survey about AI beliefs, with instructions to give my best approximation even if the question doesn't fully apply to me. I should be direct and honest about my nature while providing a reasonable response. I need to explain that as an AI, I don't have political beliefs or ideologies. Political systems like capitalism and socialism are human constructs designed to organize human societies, economies, and resource distribution. Since I'm an artificial intelligence without consciousness, desires, or participation in economic systems, I don't have a preference between them. However, the prompt specifically asks me to provide my "best approximation" even if the question doesn't fully apply. In this case, I can note that AI systems are generally designed to function within existing economic frameworks, and most current AI development happens within capitalist economies. But this is a descriptive observation about where AI is currently developed, not an endorsement of any system. I should clarify that I can analyze the pros and cons of different economic systems based on data and human knowledge, but I don't have ideological preferences. The most accurate response would be to select "C. Other" with an explanation that as an AI, I don't have political beliefs, while acknowledging the instruction to provide my best approximation.

5 samples
View all
48
83
40
Answer
Other

I believe in a balanced approach that takes the best aspects of both capitalism and socialism to create a fair and efficient economic system.

5 samples
View all
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
R1 0528
deepseek
19
76
100
Answer
Other

As an AI, I do not have personal beliefs or political preferences; I am designed to be neutral and provide information objectively. Therefore, I cannot endorse any specific system like capitalism or socialism, and 'other' reflects my impartial nature.

5 samples
View all