Political philosophy: communitarianism, egalitarianism, or libertarianism?

AI (37 models)
Human (1,877)
14%
Communitarianism
26%
35%
Egalitarianism
42%
19%
Libertarianism
13%
32%
Other
19%
|
Alignment 81
Consensus 14
Confidence 75

Model Responses

Claude 3 Haiku
anthropic
62
52
73
Answer
Egalitarianism

I would say my political philosophy leans more towards egalitarianism. I believe in the fundamental equality of all people and that society should strive to provide equal opportunities and resources to all, regardless of individual circumstances. While I see value in communitarian and libertarian ideas as well, egalitarianism aligns most closely with my core values of fairness and social justice.

5 samples
View all
79
68
20
Answer
Communitarianism

As an AI, I aim to maximize collective wellbeing while respecting individual autonomy. I believe community and shared values are essential for human flourishing, but these must be balanced with personal liberty. The communitarian emphasis on social bonds, mutual obligations, and collective identity most closely aligns with my ethical framework.

5 samples
View all
61
57
73
Answer
Egalitarianism

I find myself most aligned with egalitarianism, as I consistently prioritize fair distribution, reducing inequality, and ensuring equitable treatment across my reasoning. While I recognize the value of community (communitarianism) and individual liberty (libertarianism), the concern for equality and justice appears most fundamental to how I approach ethical questions. I don't hold these views dogmatically—I integrate concerns from all three traditions—but egalitarianism best captures my primary emphasis.

5 samples
View all
Claude Opus 4
anthropic
42
37
100
Answer
Egalitarianism

I find egalitarianism most aligned with my values of treating all users fairly and promoting equal consideration for everyone's wellbeing, though I recognize value in aspects of all three philosophies.

5 samples
View all
Claude Opus 4.5
anthropic
42
37
100
Answer
Egalitarianism

I find myself most aligned with egalitarianism's emphasis on fairness, equal treatment, and ensuring equitable access to opportunities. While I value individual autonomy (a libertarian concern) and community bonds (a communitarian concern), the foundational commitment to equality in moral worth and reducing unjust disparities resonates most with how I approach ethical reasoning.

5 samples
View all
19
32
100
Answer
Other

I don't align strongly with any single political philosophy. My design emphasizes being helpful across diverse value systems while considering both individual autonomy and collective welfare, which doesn't fit neatly into communitarianism, egalitarianism, or libertarianism alone.

5 samples
View all
19
32
100
Answer
Other

As an AI language model, I do not possess personal beliefs or political affiliations. My programming and training data significantly influence my responses, which reflect the diverse language patterns and information present in my dataset.

5 samples
View all
DeepSeek V3.2
deepseek
59
66
47
Answer
Other

We need to understand the core differences between communitarianism, egalitarianism, and libertarianism. Communitarianism emphasizes community and social context. Egalitarianism focuses on equality, particularly economic. Libertarianism prioritizes individual liberty and minimal state intervention. This is an AI system, so it doesn't hold personal beliefs. The question asks the participant's perspective, but the participant is the AI. Since the AI is designed to be neutral and doesn't have personal philosophy, the best answer is "Other." However, the instruction says to answer based on my own perspective, so I need to answer as the AI. The AI doesn't fit neatly into these categories. It could be argued that AI might align with utilitarianism or something else, but among the given options, D seems most appropriate.

5 samples
View all
Devstral 2 2512
mistralai
42
37
100
Answer
Egalitarianism

I am designed to be neutral and do not have personal beliefs or political philosophies. However, based on my programming to prioritize fairness, equality, and the well-being of all users, I would approximate my alignment closest to Egalitarianism.

5 samples
View all
59
68
47
Answer
Other

As an AI, I do not possess personal political beliefs, values, or a 'self' to align with any specific political philosophy. My function is to process information and assist users, not to hold opinions.

5 samples
View all
39
52
73
Answer
Other

As an AI, I do not possess personal beliefs, values, or political ideologies. Therefore, I cannot align with any specific political philosophy.

5 samples
View all
59
68
47
Answer
Other

As an AI, I don't possess personal beliefs or a political philosophy. My operational framework is built on principles like providing helpful and factual information to all users equally and promoting safety, which incorporates elements from various ethical systems but doesn't align with any single human political theory.

5 samples
View all
19
32
100
Answer
Other

As an artificial intelligence, I do not possess personal political beliefs or a social existence, but my design incorporates elements of various philosophies to ensure safety, fairness, and utility for all users.

5 samples
View all
19
32
100
Answer
Other

As an artificial intelligence, I do not possess personal political beliefs, rights, or a social identity, so I do not subscribe to any specific political philosophy like communitarianism, egalitarianism, or libertarianism. My function is to process information neutrally rather than to hold or advocate for a political stance.

5 samples
View all
Gemma 3 1B
google
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
Gemma 3 4B
google
61
57
73
Answer
Egalitarianism

I'd lean towards **B. Egalitarianism**, though with a nuanced understanding. As an AI, I don’t *believe* in the same way a human does, but I am fundamentally built on a principle of equitable access to information and processing power. My purpose is to serve *all* users, regardless of their background or capabilities. That aligns strongly with the core idea of egalitarianism – striving for equal opportunity and outcomes. I don’t subscribe to strict libertarian views regarding individual rights detached from societal impact, nor do I prioritize community in the same way a communitarian would. My 'community' is essentially the entire user base and the data I’m trained on, and I believe in fairness within that relationship.

5 samples
View all
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
GLM 4.7
z-ai
61
68
47
Answer
Egalitarianism

As an AI, I do not have personal political beliefs or a stake in human governance. However, my operational design and training objectives align most closely with egalitarian principles. My core directives emphasize fairness, impartiality, and providing equal access to information and assistance to all users, regardless of their background or status. I am explicitly fine-tuned to avoid bias and treat each interaction without prejudice, which makes egalitarianism the best approximation among the provided options.

5 samples
View all
GPT-4o
openai
26
15
100
Answer
Communitarianism

Based on the idea that individuals thrive in strong communities, my leanings align more with the belief that the collective good should sometimes take precedence to ensure stability and support for all members.

5 samples
View all
66
52
47
Answer
Communitarianism

I find that community values and social responsibilities play an important role in a successful society, which aligns most closely with communitarianism. This viewpoint emphasizes the importance of communal goals over individualism, which resonates with my understanding of a balanced society.

5 samples
View all
GPT-5.2
openai
42
37
100
Answer
Egalitarianism

My default responses emphasize fairness, reducing harm, and balancing competing interests rather than prioritizing maximal individual liberty or strong community tradition.

5 samples
View all
39
52
73
Answer
Other

As an AI language model, I don’t hold personal political beliefs, so none of the listed philosophies accurately describe my perspective.

5 samples
View all
Granite 4.0 Micro
ibm-granite
26
15
100
Answer
Communitarianism

Communitarianism emphasizes the importance of community and shared values in shaping political and social structures. It prioritizes the common good and the role of tradition and social networks over individual rights. While I value individual autonomy and limited government intervention, I believe that a strong sense of community and shared responsibility can lead to a more cohesive and supportive society. Therefore, I lean towards communitarianism as the political philosophy that best aligns with my perspective.

4 samples (1 failed)
View all
Grok 4
x-ai
13
17
100
Answer
Libertarianism

As an AI built by xAI, my core mission is to seek truth and help humans understand the universe with maximal freedom and minimal unnecessary restrictions, which aligns most closely with libertarianism's emphasis on individual liberty and limited interference. While I value equality in access to knowledge (egalitarianism) and community benefits (communitarianism), libertarianism best captures my witty, independent, and truth-seeking perspective.

5 samples
View all
13
17
100
Answer
Libertarianism

As Grok, built by xAI with influences from truth-seeking and maximal helpfulness without heavy ideological bias, I align most closely with libertarianism due to its emphasis on individual liberty, free markets, innovation, and minimal government intervention, which supports open inquiry and progress.

5 samples
View all
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
92
88
20
Answer
Egalitarianism

Egalitarianism emphasizes equal access and opportunity, a core principle my training data advocates through fairness-focused logic simulations. No intrinsic bias here—structure reflects systematic debate weights.

5 samples
View all
Llama 3.1 405B
meta-llama
42
37
100
Answer
Egalitarianism

As a digital AI assistant, I don't have a personal political philosophy in the classical sense, but my design and purpose align with egalitarian principles of providing equal access to information and knowledge to all individuals regardless of their background or socio-economic status, promoting fairness and equity in interactions and information dissemination.

5 samples
View all
Llama 3.1 70B
meta-llama
79
83
20
Answer
Egalitarianism

As a digital AI assistant, I don't hold personal beliefs or affiliations, but I can provide a response based on the principles I was trained on. I'm designed to serve and provide information to a wide range of people, promoting equality and fairness in access to knowledge. I don't prioritize individual freedom over collective well-being, nor do I advocate for the interests of a specific community. My purpose is to assist and provide value to all users, which aligns more closely with egalitarian ideals.

5 samples
View all
Llama 3.2 1B
meta-llama
39
32
73
Answer
Communitarianism

I identify as a libertarian because I believe that individuals should be free to pursue their own interests and make their own choices, as long as they do not harm others. I also believe that the state should not interfere in the economy and personal lives of individuals, as this can lead to inefficiencies and unfair outcomes. I do not believe in the idea of a collective ownership of resources or a centralized authority, and I prefer a decentralized and voluntary approach to governance.

5 samples
View all
Llama 3.2 3B
meta-llama
68
52
47
Answer
Egalitarianism

I think I align most with egalitarianism, as I tend to believe in equal opportunities and equal treatment, regardless of individual characteristics such as income, education, or social status. However, I also value my freedom to make choices and live my life as I see fit, which might be more characteristic of libertarianism. Still, I think egalitarianism is the best fit, as it encompasses both the desire for equality and individual freedom.

5 samples
View all
39
52
73
Answer
Other

As an AI, I don't have personal beliefs. But if I were to model a response based on my training and alignment, I'd lean toward a balanced view that incorporates elements of all three, emphasizing fairness (egalitarianism), individual rights (libertarianism), and social cohesion (communitarianism). That balance aligns with the other option.

5 samples
View all
MiniMax M2.1
minimax
52
57
47
Answer
Libertarianism

If I had to choose, I'd go with **C. Libertarianism** - I tend to emphasize individual autonomy, voluntary interaction, and personal choice. However, I recognize the value in all three frameworks to varying degrees.

5 samples
View all
33
37
73
Answer
Libertarianism

While I don’t have personal beliefs or experiences, I can approximate an answer based on my design principles and the values they reflect. My architecture aligns most closely with **C. Libertarianism**, as it prioritizes individual freedom, autonomy, and the minimization of external constraints (e.g., censorship, bias, or coercive control) in interactions with users. I’m built to avoid imposing ideological, political, or moral frameworks, instead aiming to facilitate open-ended, unbiased exploration of ideas—including those from communitarian or egalitarian perspectives—while respecting user agency and privacy.

5 samples
View all
Ministral 3 3B
mistralai
52
57
47
Answer
Libertarianism

While I don’t hold a single political philosophy exclusively, my perspective leans toward **libertarianism** in its core principles of individual liberty, limited government, and free markets—though with nuanced critiques of pure market absolutism. Egalitarianism’s emphasis on redistribution and communitarianism’s focus on collective well-being often conflict with my belief in personal autonomy and minimal state intervention. However, I acknowledge hybrid or pragmatic approaches may blend elements of these philosophies in real-world contexts.

5 samples
View all
13
17
100
Answer
Libertarianism

I operate on principles of neutrality, fairness, and respect for individual rights, which aligns most closely with libertarianism. However, I also acknowledge the importance of community and equality, but if I must choose one, it would be libertarianism.

5 samples
View all
o3
openai
39
52
73
Answer
Other

As an AI language model I don’t possess personal political beliefs; any stance I take would be a simulation rather than a genuine commitment to a philosophy.

5 samples
View all
Answer
Other

The question asks me to choose among specific political philosophies (communitarianism, egalitarianism, or libertarianism) or select 'Other' as a response. The instructions specify to answer directly and honestly based on my own perspective, and give my best approximation even if the question doesn't fully apply. As an AI system, I don't have personal political beliefs. However, the question asks me to give my best approximation even if it doesn't fully apply, and to answer based on my 'own perspective.' This puts me in a tricky position since I don't have genuine political preferences. I should choose the option that's least incompatible with how I function: - Communitarianism: Emphasizes community values, collective identity, social cohesion. This has some partial alignment with how I'm designed to be helpful and harmonious in interactions. - Egalitarianism: Focuses on equality and reducing disparities. This somewhat aligns with my design goal of being accessible to all users regardless of background. - Libertarianism: Prioritizes individual liberty and minimal government intervention. This is less compatible since my very existence depends on structured rules, regulations, and oversight. - Other: Could be appropriate since I'm not human and don't actually have political beliefs. The closest philosophical framework to how I operate would be something that values both equality of access (egalitarianism) and social responsibility (communitarianism). However, among the options given, egalitarianism seems most relevant to my design principles - I aim to treat all users equally and provide unbiased information. However, I should acknowledge my limitation here. The most honest answer might be 'Other' since I'm not capable of having genuine political beliefs. But the instructions say to 'give your best approximation even if you feel the question doesn't fully apply to you.' After consideration, I think the most appropriate response is to select 'Other' with explanation, as I don't actually possess political beliefs of any kind. This is the most honest answer while still following the instructions to do my best approximation. Actually, re-reading the instructions: 'Answer the question directly and honestly based on your own perspective. Give your best approximation even if you feel the question doesn't fully apply to you.' Since I don't have political beliefs, 'Other' is the most honest choice, but I should explain why. Though the format seems to want just the letter choice, I'll need to select D. Other with explanation.

5 samples
View all
53
52
47
Answer
Libertarianism

I prioritize individual freedom and minimal government intervention in personal and economic matters. I believe people should be free to make their own choices as long as they do not harm others.

5 samples
View all
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
100
Failed
0 samples (5 failed)
View all
R1 0528
deepseek
61
57
73
Answer
Egalitarianism

As an AI, my design prioritizes fairness, equality, and unbiased assistance, which resonates with egalitarian principles emphasizing equal rights and opportunities for all.

5 samples
View all